Indicator: Growth mindset
Definition
Students believe that their abilities can grow with effort.
RECOMMENDED METRIC(S)
K–12: Percentage of students reporting a high level of growth mindset on surveys such as the CORE Districts SEL Survey Growth Mindset Scale (grades 5–12) or the Growth Mindset Scale developed by Carol Dweck, which may be used with children, teens, and adults
Postsecondary and workforce: Percentage of students reporting a high level of growth mindset on surveys such as the Growth Mindset Scale developed by Carol Dweck
Type(s) of Data Needed
SurveysWhy it matters
A growth mindset has been linked to better attendance, behavior, and math and English language arts test scores. In particular, the belief that math ability is fixed or innate is especially common, and may limit learning in math. Research shows that traditionally underserved students—including students experiencing poverty, emerging multilingual learners, and Latino and Black students—are less likely to hold a growth mindset than their peers. Some interventions with K–12 and college students that foster a growth mindset have been shown to improve students’ grade point averages (GPAs), reduce course failures, and support academic effort. However, a recent meta-analysis of 29 mindset interventions found that, on average, they had limited effects on student outcomes. Growth mindset interventions may help narrow differences in academic achievement between students of color and White students; however, research findings are inconsistent—for example, one study found that growth mindset interventions significantly improved the academic performance of Latino students, but not Black students, and other studies have not been able to replicate positive impacts among diverse populations of students.
What to know about measurement
As indicated above, several survey tools exist to measure this indicator and related constructs. We have identified and suggested tools with an evidence base; however, other instruments may also be appropriate to measure this indicator, though the use of different instruments across contexts would reduce comparability of this indicator. Please see information on the self-management indicator for additional considerations regarding the measurement of social-emotional skills.
E-W Case Studies
Source frameworks
This indicator appeared in three source frameworks reviewed for this report. Our proposed definition and measure align with the CORE Districts definition of growth mindset. Broadly, we have opted to align with—and build on—CORE Districts SEL indicators, given the evidence base for their predictive power and instrumentation.
References
The framework's recommendations are based on syntheses of existing research. Please see the framework report for a list of works cited.