Skip to main content

Indicator: Employment in a quality job

Definition

Individuals are employed in a position that offers a living wage, benefits, stable and predictable schedules, clear and fair advancement to higher pay, safe conditions, and job security.

RECOMMENDED METRIC(S)

Percentage of individuals employed in a quality job, as defined by scores on an indexed measure, such as the Good Jobs Scorecard, which assesses pay and benefits, scheduling, potential career paths, safety, and security

Type(s) of Data Needed

Surveys

Why it matters

According to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), job quality is a key determinant of individual well-being. Higher wages and benefits are associated with multiple aspects of worker well-being, including life satisfaction, mortality, wealth accumulation, and mental health. A living wage is defined as “the minimum economic standard that, if met, draws a very fine line between the financial independence of the working poor and the need to seek out public assistance or suffer consistent and severe housing and food insecurity.” As this definition by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Living Wage Calculator indicates, a living wage is a minimum threshold, yet it typically exceeds the minimum wage. For instance, the living wage for a single mother with one child in the Atlanta metropolitan area is $30.74 per hour—more than four times higher than the local minimum wage of $7.25.621 For those who pursue postsecondary education, it is also important to consider whether they are earning what they expect to earn in their field beyond the living wage threshold.xiv

Non-economic aspects of job quality also matter for workers’ well-being and success. A recent study shows that aspects of job quality, such as stable and predictable scheduling and room for upward growth within a company, are meaningful to low-wage workers, defined as those earning less than approximately $40,000 per year. As with wages, there are disparities in other aspects of job quality. For instance, less than half of low-wage workers report having a supervisor who offers them flexibility regarding work-life balance, with only 29 percent of Latino respondents reporting sufficient flexibility compared with 40 percent of White workers and 43 percent of Black workers.


xiv This is what the Postsecondary Value Commission calls “earnings premium.”

What to know about measurement

There are a variety of definitions and frameworks related to job quality, and there is no field-wide consensus on the definition of a “quality job.” Our proposed definition and measure draw on recommendations from the MIT Good Jobs Institute, but other job quality frameworks include the U.S. Departments of Commerce and Labor Good Jobs Principles, which offer eight principles of a good job, as well as the Jobs for the Future Quality Jobs Framework, which defines standards for quality jobs across four dimensions. Differences in the nature of work across industries and geographies pose challenges to establishing a standard measure of job quality that applies across contexts, as does the availability of job data beyond wages. However, despite the definitional variation that exists, the job quality frameworks referenced here all share common elements including fair pay, opportunities for advancement, and workplace safety. We see this indicator as an area where the framework can promote a more widely validated and used measure. E-W institutions, such as school districts and colleges, may measure this indicator among their graduates by linking K–12, postsecondary, and workforce data.

We also note that underemployment is a related subject on which research continues to emerge. No single definition exists, but underemployment generally refers to situations in which college graduates are employed in jobs that “do not require or make meaningful use of a college degree.”  Underemployment is persistent: nearly three-quarters of graduates who are underemployed in their first job after college remain underemployed 10 years later. Persistent unemployment has long-term economic consequences, as it limits workers’ earning potential over time, thus highlighting the importance of securing a quality job early in one’s career.

Source frameworks

This indicator appeared in 10 source frameworks reviewed for this report. Our proposed definition and measure draw on work by the MIT Good Jobs Institute.

References

The framework's recommendations are based on syntheses of existing research. Please see the framework report for a list of works cited.